Canada's most populous province is proposing to eliminate the mandatory reporting of carbon pollution from the fuel sold by oil and gas companies — a requirement that is among the last remnants of Ontario’s cap and trade program.
Ontario Premier Doug Ford's government said Thursday that it was "streamlining and updating" its greenhouse gas emissions program "to reduce unnecessary costs and regulatory burden." A public consultation on the matter is open until March 8.
The government is looking to remove mandatory reporting and verification for the emissions from fuel sold by Ontario oil and gas companies. Industry would no longer have to report on emissions coming from "the consumption of the fuels they supply or distribute."
Fight disinformation with facts. Support the Election Integrity Reporting Project!
This data "is no longer needed," said a spokesperson for the Ontario Environment Ministry in an emailed statement, since the former Liberal government’s cap and trade program was canceled by the Ford government in November 2018.
The requirement had stemmed from a compliance obligation under the former cap and trade program.
The proposal to make these changes was posted on the Environmental Registry of Ontario at midnight Feb. 7. It targets petroleum product suppliers, natural gas distributors and other large emitters, and seeks to adopt federal emissions data so as to reduce the reporting burden on the province and ensure that reporting is not duplicated.
The reporting of direct emissions would still be mandatory, including emissions produced by refining facilities and pipelines. The changes “would have no impact on how the government tracks emissions from these sources,” the proposal notice stated.
"The proposed change relates only to reporting on the emission from the fuel (industries) sell," said the spokesperson.
It wasn’t immediately clear whether the Ontario government would still be able to calculate the breakdown of emissions from the fuel sold by oil and gas companies if it followed through with its proposal.
The environmental registry posting states that the provincial emissions inventory “has always used data from the federal National Inventory Report for these emission sources,” referring to Canada’s official submission to the United Nations climate change framework.
This data would continue to be used to track progress for Ontario’s 2030 emissions target, it said. Ontario aims to reduce carbon pollution by 30 per cent from 2005 levels.
Housekeeping, or roadblock?
Environmental economists and advocates said Thursday they were unsure whether the government’s proposal amounted to an administrative move, or if it had deeper implications for the ability of officials to accurately track carbon pollution. The Ford government has attacked the Trudeau Liberals on their plan to price pollution nationwide, and launched a constitutional legal challenge against it.
The federal carbon pricing system includes a fuels charge that kicks in for Ontario beginning in April. The fuels charge requires fuel suppliers to reduce the emissions intensity of the fuels they sell. In order to do that, the fuel being sold must be compared against a federally-designed baseline. Veronica Petro, a spokesperson for Environment and Climate Change Canada, told National Observer in an email the these proposed chance "does not impact the implementation of the federal carbon pollution pricing system."
The federal emissions reporting requirements are largely similar to those in Ontario and employ the same threshold for greenhouse gas emissions, Petro said. It wasn't clear if emissions were fuel sales were included in these requirements, although Petro said "the federal program has also been expanding its requirements to collect additional information related to emissions from facilities in specific industry sectors, and to require the use of specific methods to determine their emissions."
Ontario's proposed changes, then, "could actually be a reasonable housekeeping measure if in fact the (federal government) has all this data, because when it comes to implementing the clean fuel standard and the impending carbon backstop, data is key,” Greenpeace senior strategist Keith Stewart said in an interview.“If, however, this is an attempt to throw a roadblock in the place of policies the Ford government doesn’t like, by making accessing data harder. then that’s a problem,” Stewart added.
“If, however, this is an attempt to throw a roadblock in the place of policies the Ford government doesn’t like, by making accessing data harder. then that’s a problem,” Stewart added.
“This move may reduce our understanding of the effects of emissions from the fuel industries sell,” said Ontario Green Party leader and MPP Mike Schreiner in an email. “Timely, accurate emissions information will help us optimize climate action.”
This notice of regulation by Ontario explains what they are proposing for GHG data collection and reporting. If it can be done at less cost to companies and taxpayers, including using shared federal data, that's good. https://t.co/lXycS6hRGZ— David McLaughlin (@DavidMcLA) February 7, 2019
The opposition NDP saw the changes as an anti-environmental decision. MPP Ian Arthur said in a statement the proposal was “yet another demonstration of Doug Ford’s willingness to attack our environment, and his refusal to take action on climate change.”
The proposal is also seeking to update how the government calculates the damage caused by different greenhouse gases to the atmosphere, by aligning it with United Nations standards.
Finally, it proposes removing verification for some entities that have to report carbon pollution. Ontario’s environmental plan said it would set “emissions performance standards” for large polluters that don’t meet industry-specific targets.
The government is asking for feedback in its consultation in regards to three questions:
“Should Ontario harmonize with the federal reporting requirements under the Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program (GHGRP) (e.g., mandatory methods, Global Warming)?”
“Should Ontario continue to require reporting of fuel distribution/supply reporting?”
“Should third party verification of emissions requirement be maintained for the voluntary participants?”
Editor's note: This story was updated on Feb. 9, 2019 at 8:30 p.m. with comments from Environment and Climate Change Canada.