OTTAWA — Former Alberta premier Jason Kenney accused the federal government of leaving provinces "holding the bag" to clear "Freedom Convoy" protesters who blockaded a border crossing in southern Alberta, a public inquiry has learned.
Documents released Tuesday by the inquiry looking into the government's decision to invoke the Emergencies Act last winter include text messages between three federal cabinet ministers, including Intergovernmental Affairs Minister Dominic LeBlanc.
In messages that LeBlanc told his cabinet colleagues he had received from Kenney, the then-premier accused Ottawa of not caring about the Canada-U.S. border closure in Coutts, Alta., and complained about the federal decision to decline Alberta's request for military equipment that could help remove protest vehicles.
LeBlanc, whose job is to work directly with provincial leaders, sent the messages to Transport Minister Omar Alghabra and Public Safety Minister Marco Mendicino on Feb. 11, three days before the Alberta RCMP moved in to make arrests in Coutts.
One message in the group chat, which LeBlanc attributed to Kenney, said: "Your guy has really screwed the pooch."
"This trucker vax policy is obviously just dumb political theatre," the message said, apparently referring to a federal policy requiring COVID-19 vaccination for cross-border truckers. The policy sparked the convoy protests, which ultimately saw demonstrators railing against other COVID-19 restrictions and the federal government.
"Calling them all Nazis hasn't exactly helped. And now the provinces are holding the bag on enforcement," the message read.
What people are reading
The message continued with an allegation that private vendors would not provide tow trucks or other heavy equipment to "move these freakin' trucks" because protesters, described as "crazies," were making death threats.
"And you guys turned down our request for army equipment to help us. Because apparently, the Government of Canada doesn't really care about the international border being closed," the message said.
"But don't worry, the RCMP commander in Alberta just told me proudly that he has secured some psychologists to do a profile assessment on the protesters. I said, 'That's great news, deputy commissioner, do any of them know how to drive a tow truck?'"
In response to the texts that LeBlanc said were from Kenney, Alghabra wrote: "Speaking of bonkers." LeBlanc replied: "Totally." Further text messages in the conversation were not released.
The blockade in Coutts forced the closure of the highway and border crossing for more than two weeks before it was broken up on Feb. 14, when RCMP seized guns and charged four men with conspiracy to commit murder.
The same day, the federal government moved to invoke the Emergencies Act in response to continued protests in downtown Ottawa.
When a commission lawyer asked LeBlanc whether Kenney was referring to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in the message that had him say "Your guy has really screwed the pooch," LeBlanc testified he did not ask.
"This text message was the premier empathically expressing his frustration," he said.
It's not the first time the commission has seen testy exchanges between federal ministers and their provincial counterparts, particularly in Ontario.
The commission has heard that members of the federal cabinet were frustrated with what they considered to be a lack of willingness from the Ontario government to come to the table to hammer out a solution to the blockades.
Earlier in the day, the public inquiry was shown a text message from Mendicino's chief of staff, Mike Jones, who back in February said Ontario's former solicitor-general Sylvia Jones used an expletive when communicating how she didn't "take edicts."
The Ontario government did not respond to a request for comment on Tuesday.
The Public Order Emergency Commission, which is in its final week, has previously heard Trudeau's cabinet was highly concerned about the possibility that the "Freedom Convoy" might inspire further protests after demonstrators set up a blockade in Coutts and another six-day border closure in Windsor, Ont.
The inability of authorities to convince or find tow truck operators willing to remove protest vehicles was one of the reasons Trudeau's government has argued the Emergencies Act was necessary because it gave law enforcement the authority to compel companies to do the job.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 22, 2022.
I can see why this text from
I can see why this text from Kenney was plucked from all the testimony: the sheer vitriol was entertaining but it also wholly encapsulates the prevailing and strikingly juvenile conservative narrative in this country: irrational and resentful hostility toward the federal government on principle, as with a powerful parent, simultaneously expecting them to fix EVERYTHING and take care of you while studiously ignoring the fact that during the pandemic Alberta received more federal money per capita than any other province. Danielle Smith is predictably and daringly all over this favorite, despite its glaring stupidity, showing a weary public yet again that these people don't know enough to even come in out of the rain.
But Liberals obviously deserve this virulent disdain by virtue of actually embodying the progressivism that makes them the "natural governing party" of this country; I mean who wants PROGRESS? And Justin Trudeau in particular? He has the nerve to
be beautiful and able to dance when their dear leader Harper can barely walk respectably. Kenney's joke in text about using psychology also reminded us of conservative anti-intellectualism, remember Harper's contempt for those who "practise sociology?"
But to the text, it unwittingly and unusually aligns with the majority of Canadians by wanting and kind of expecting the military to intervene, thereby validating the evocation of the Emergencies Act with its lower bar that still did the job.
And of course we should keep
And of course we should keep in mind that Kenney would have been frothing no matter what the federal government did. If they'd moved fast to clear the border, he would have said they were trampling on provincial rights.