Ontario was on the “right track” with its climate policies before Doug Ford’s government “swept away” most of them and replaced them with nothing, says Ontario’s environment watchdog.
Ford’s bill to repeal cap and trade “lacks most of the features of good climate law,” Dianne Saxe, Ontario’s environmental commissioner, said in her annual report released Tuesday. Greenhouse gas emissions were down in large part due to policies of the former Liberal government that his Conservatives are scrapping, the report said.
Without the $1.9 billion revenue from the cap and trade carbon emissions market that Ford has branded a “job killing carbon tax,” she said Ontario will have to find new ways to fund climate solutions. One way is ending fossil fuel subsidies.
The Cap and Trade Cancellation Act (Bill 4) doesn’t offer a clear path ahead, she said.
“Instead it promises undetermined action to achieve undetermined and easily changed targets at some undetermined future time with no criteria and no consequences,” Saxe said at a presentation Tuesday. “It’s a license to do little or nothing in the face of our largest threat.”
It’s not too late to reduce the damage that is coming, the report said. Canada had made important international commitments to do its fair share in reducing global emissions. "Ontario can, and must, do its part," says the report.
Ford’s government, since being sworn in June 29, has undone several measures of the former Liberal government that the commissioner credited for driving down Ontario’s greenhouse gas emissions to a record low in 2016.
Noting that First Nations communities had a stake in eight of the 10 largest green energy projects that Ford has cancelled, Saxe said: “Environmental justice has to be part of … reconciliation."
“It is no longer possible for us to have what we all want: both a safe, predictable climate that sustains our lives and economy and unlimited fossil fuel use,” the report said. “Like other places, Ontario must take most fossil fuels and other sources of greenhouse gases out of our economy, and soon.”
Public should speak up
Like Greenpeace, Saxe expressed concern that the government had failed to live up to its obligation to consult the public on significant changes to climate policy.
On Sept. 11, Greenpeace sued Ontario for failing to comply with the Ontario Environmental Bill of Rights by killing regulations that underpinned cap and trade in July without conducting consultations.
Within hours of Ecojustice filing the lawsuit on behalf of Greenpeace, the government opened public consultations on the Cap and Trade Cancellation Act for the legal minimum of 30 days, ending Oct. 11.
Environment Minister Rod Phillips had asserted that the recent Ontario election was a process of public participation that was substantially equivalent to the process required under the environmental bill of rights.
"The recent Ontario election was not a lawful substitute for the process of public participation required by the Environmental Bill of Rights,” the Saxe report said. “The public’s EBR right to participate is distinct from the democratic mandate created by elections, and was specifically created to address the erosion of public trust in environmentally significant decisions of democratically elected governments.”
Saxe said she was pleased that Phillips had recognized his legal obligations. But, “what the government hasn’t done in that consultation is tell people actually what it plans to do. It's very difficult for people to comment without knowing what government really means to do.”
Keith Stewart, senior energy strategist with Greenpeace Canada, told National Observer that while the suit will no longer receive an expedited hearing since Bill 4 is up for consultation, they still seek a ruling that confirms a government cannot consider an election campaign a legitimate consultation under the Environmental Bill of Rights.
He said the absence of a government plan to replace cap and trade and other policies “is in itself a plan. It's a plan to do nothing.”
‘We need a backbone’
Ford campaigned aggressively on pulling Ontario from the carbon market it shared with Quebec and California, and the legislation to repeal it, says Saxe, ought to have targets in place for emissions reductions.
“There has been some suggestion that the cap and trade money was being taken unjustly from Ontario families and businesses and then wasted,” Saxe said. “That is not what I found.”
She said the program was complex and "poorly communicated," but it was on its way to producing economic and environmental benefits. Together with closure of coal plants, slowing urban sprawl and other measures, she said, "these were good policies that worked."
Saxe said she hopes Ontarians will participate in the online consultation to let government know where they stand. The government might be open to suggestions on replacing cap and trade.
“All we have right now is the bill itself,” Saxe told National Observer, referring to the bill to repeal cap and trade. “And the bill itself is utterly bare bones. And I don't think Ontarians should accept that. That will not give any backbone to any kind of climate action. It's more likely to be a fig leaf than a backbone. We need a backbone. And I hope Ontarians will speak up for one.”
Updated at 455 PM ET with quotes from environmental commissioner Dianne Saxe and comment by environmental organizations.
Today's must read
Convoy mixes with white nationalists and delivers toxic message to Ottawa
Sheila Watt-Cloutier urges bankers to take bold risks to fight climate change
Canada's top public servant fears 'someone is going to be shot' in next election campaign
Climate change plays major role in top 10 underreported humanitarian crises of 2018: report
Canada's health organizations demand action to prevent catastrophic climate change
Montreal man ticketed for doing exactly what every other Montrealer has done this winter
Alberta hikes minimum wage, adds food service jobs for the third straight year
Mike Schreiner aims to protect water in Ontario’s first-ever Green Party bill
Scattered relatives of seven Halifax children who died in fire speak of anguish
What would a 10-year ban on federal contracts actually mean for SNC-Lavalin?
B.C. provincial budget funds nearly $1 billion for climate action
Get to know the Green New Deal, by the numbers
Alberta says GHG reductions prove carbon pricing works
Tech giants called to testify in Ottawa in international probe of fake news
Climate change isn’t just frying the planet—it’s fraying our nerves
Doug Ford just urged Ontario students to wash their mouths out with soap
Water monitors are getting a new tool to tackle toxic algae in Lake Winnipeg
Canadian regulator won't consider climate impacts of Trans Mountain
Alberta expands oil-by-rail capacity by 120,000 barrels per day
Gerald Butts resigns from PMO
Tories are 'joyous' about departure of 'feared' Trudeau advisor
Five things you should know about Gerald Butts, following his resignation
Sidewalk Labs plans massive takeover of Toronto neighbourhood
'Making this up': Study says oilsands assessments marred by weak science
Former B.C. premier Gordon Campbell accused of sexual assault: British newspaper
Wilson-Raybould snubbed Senate committee on corporate corruption bill
Trump's national emergency: from shutdown frying pan to constitutional fire
'People will die if nothing is done'
Scientist who resisted censorship of climate report lost her job
What is the Green New Deal and how would it benefit society?
Urgency in climate change advocacy is backfiring, says Citizen Potawatomi Nation scientist
A lawsuit to save Ontario's basic income program has failed
'It’s like pulling teeth': Catherine McKenna accused of stalling on fossil fuel subsidies
Indigenous technologists using tech tools as path to self-determination
Public outrage growing over Doug Ford's 'crazy' comments
How Trudeau's climate promise fizzled
We asked Rod Phillips to explain how Ontario's latest proposal is different from a carbon tax
Oil and gas industry rewards fossil fuel growth at its peril, report warns
Why François Legault is wrong about Islamophobia in Quebec
Wilson-Raybould resignation spells trouble for Liberals
Trudeau 'surprised' by Wilson-Raybould's resignation
Doug Ford’s government just proposed a carbon tax on industry
Why a UN committee’s new Site C deadline shouldn’t be ignored
Parliamentary watchdog rejects Morneau's criticism of its Trans Mountain report
Comments