As droughts, deteriorating farmland and rising sea levels push people around the world from their homes, advocates in Canada are calling on the federal government to support those who are — and will be — displaced by the climate crisis.
Last week, Climate Action Network Canada (CAN-Rac), a body of more than 100 environmental groups across the country, sent a letter to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Immigration Minister Sean Fraser asking them to grant permanent residency to all 1.7 million migrants in Canada, including half a million undocumented people. This “regularization” process is key to climate justice, explained Caroline Brouillette, national policy manager for CAN-Rac.
“Fighting the climate crisis is not only about reducing our emissions, it’s about how we care for one another — and that’s why we’re asking for this,” she said.
Climate change is already a factor causing people to immigrate to Canada, said Syed Hussan, the executive director of the Migrant Workers Alliance for Change (MWAC), which worked with CAN-Rac to send the letter. But while climate migrants come to the country as workers, students or refugees, they “may not even be able to describe their experiences having resulted from climate change.”
He said many migrants' understanding of climate change is that it causes poverty.
“[Climate change is] actually closely linked to economic deterioration,” Hussan explained.
Take farmers, for example. Soil degradation is one of climate change's greatest impacts, he said. Poor soil means poor crops, forcing farmers to move to towns and cities to find work. But many fail to find jobs in larger urban centres, he added, leaving them no choice but to leave their home country and seek opportunities in Canada.
What people are reading
Alongside poor crops, water scarcity and rising sea levels are among the top drivers that the World Bank predicts will force 216 million people to migrate within their own countries by 2050. This estimate doesn’t account for people in Europe, North America, the Middle East or small island developing states like Barbados or Kiribati.
“For many people, the only option is to come here on some sort of a temporary permit,” Hussan said.
Once they make it to Canada, many still face considerable hardship — which is why MWAC is advocating for all migrants, including temporary foreign workers, to be granted permanent residency. “A person without permanent residency [or] citizenship does not have equal rights in Canada,” Hussan said.
A recent example is a group of Jamaican migrant farm workers in Ontario who wrote an open letter to Jamaican Labour Minister Karl Samuda earlier this month saying they were experiencing “systematic slavery,” with extremely poor working conditions that included crowded housing, exposure to dangerous pesticides and verbally abusive employers.
Hussan said MWAC plans to propose a “permanent regularization program” to the federal government in the future but didn’t say exactly what this would look like — other than that it would allow for “everyone in the country [to have] the same immigration status and the same rights.”
Creating new migration pathways
Meanwhile, some groups are calling on the government to make climate change a viable reason for migrants to get permanent residency in Canada. Last year, the Canadian Association of Refugee Lawyers (CARL) published a report outlining several options the federal government could take.
It’s not feasible for climate migrants to come to Canada as refugees, said Rachel Bryce, an associate lawyer at Landings Law and also the co-chair of CARL. Under Canadian law, refugees are defined strictly as people outside their home country with a well-founded fear of persecution due to their race, religion, social group or political opinion.
CARL wants Canada to allow climate migrants to gain status under protected persons legislation. This is available for people already in Canada who do not qualify as refugees but would face significant risk if they returned to their home country.
“If you don’t fall under that [refugee] definition but still face a serious risk to your life — which could be something like gang violence or, as CARL is suggesting, climate impacts that affect people's right to life,” Bryce said.
Adding climate migrants to the protected persons category would pave the way to permanent residency if a person could prove their home country is no longer safe due to climate change impacts.
Adding a specific climate change class to “protected persons” would require changing the law. But it would also be possible to further amend the Immigration and Refugee Act to allow climate migrants to stay on humanitarian and compassionate grounds, Bryce said.
Canada is both one of the world’s largest emitters of greenhouse gases and one of its biggest fossil fuel producers — and has responsibility to bear for the climate crisis, Brouillette said. CAN-Rac has also stressed the importance of Canada taking action to reduce its emissions.
“It’s about Canada doing its fair share of the global effort to limit warming to 1.5 degrees and to take responsibility for our disproportionate contribution to the crisis,” Brouillette said.
I don't think many if not
I don't think many if not most Canadians realize how racist we Canadians are. We should welcome climate migrants as many are not only familiar with agriculture but are willing to work in rural Canada, in agriculture. Some help from our provincial and federal governments would be in order. And there will be 10s of millions of Climate migrants over the next few decades as drought, weather patterns changes, and floods make living and survival in many areas untenable. As I listen to some of my fellow seniors complain about Trudeau and his supposed policy of only allowing brown immigrants into Canada, I wonder what planet they live on. And some are former teachers! There are no countries in this wide world with a predominantly white population who have excess people willing to come to Canada. And if you think we have a crisis in our medical system now, imagine it with no brown folks, from medical pros, to cleaners and all those jobs in between. Let's welcome immigrants whether Climate refugees, political or war refugees or just folks who want their children to have a better life.
I'm not seeing the main
I'm not seeing the main problem with immigration as racism, but rather unwillingness to allow immigrants who are poor and/or uneducated/illiterate, with no one willing to undertake the financial sponsorship period, which can be up to 10 years.
There has always been a general lack of understanding amongst those who've "been here longer" as to the benefits immigrants have brought. There was significant discrimination against immigrants from various parts of Europe, from the late 1800s through the post WW2 years.
As long as you have the requisite amount of money to show the government, don't have a criminal record, and have no serious health issues, no problemo.
OTOH, it sounds like the agricultural work is entirely seasonal, and probably not enough to support a family here. Once the "able to support oneself" piece and the number of family members that would be covered on the same application is put together, it doesn't seem likely that the family wouldn't have to access social assistance benefits. That's probably the piece that needs to be addressed.
Along with the provisions of employment law that allow bosses to demand excessive working hours in a day and no time off. I was shocked at the changes that Mike Harris made, particularly to overtime provisions.